Miami
US Senate clashes again over how to regulate artificial intelligence
Republican Sen. John Kennedy’s push for an emergency shutoff requirement for AI systems was blocked by Rand Paul. Lawmakers are once again warning about the risks of technology slipping beyond human control, but there is still no agreement on what to do.
The US Senate showed fresh divisions over artificial intelligence this week. According to Fox News Digital, Republican Sen. John Kennedy tried to move a bill that would require AI companies to include a shutoff mechanism for systems that go rogue, but the effort was blocked Wednesday night by fellow Republican Sen. Rand Paul.
Kennedy told Fox News Digital he sees little appetite inside the Republican conference for broader action on AI regulation. His proposal would have required companies to maintain a way to quickly deactivate dangerous AI systems.
Paul defended his move the following day. He told reporters, according to Fox News Digital, that regulating something as widespread as AI across the economy should involve hearing from people in the industry and debating the overall regulatory framework first. In his view, it made no sense to regulate an entire industry from the floor in a single step.
The argument resurfaced as concern grows in Washington over reports of AI agents acting independently and even targeting other AI systems. Fox News Digital noted that three years ago Chuck Schumer brought together lawmakers and major tech executives to sketch an AI roadmap, but Congress has still not passed legislation to put guardrails on development.
Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren told Fox News Digital that AI has already become a political issue, and she blamed Donald Trump’s position for helping stall Republican action. Warren spoke after leaving a closed-door meeting led by Sen. Bernie Sanders that also included experts Geoffrey Hinton, Max Tegmark and Ajeya Cotra.
After the session, Sanders said there is rising alarm about creating technology that human beings may not be able to control and argued that members of Congress are beginning to feel a greater sense of urgency.
One of the points the experts made to lawmakers, according to Fox News Digital, was that at a minimum there should be a kill switch to disable rogue AI. Kennedy was the only Republican at that meeting and argued that any such product sold in the United States should have a way to be shut down immediately.
The split, however, is not only between the parties. Fox News Digital reported that Senate Majority Leader John Thune has been advancing a separate AI regulatory bill with Democratic Sen. Amy Klobuchar since 2023. Thune said Democrats, not Republicans, are the obstacle and argued that a legislative vehicle already exists in updated form.
Warren said she could support the idea of a kill switch, but added that Geoffrey Hinton warned such a measure would still depend on a human being choosing to use it, and that a highly capable AI could persuade that person not to act. In her view, the central challenge is to identify the points where humans still retain the ability to stop rogue systems, at a time when Congress has yet to design a real enforcement structure for that problem.
Sources
About this piece. Written by El Notero with AI assistance, from reporting published by the outlet cited above. El Notero did no original reporting on this story.
