World
REINO UNIDO UK government warns barristers over use of rape myths after Russell Brand case
Justice Secretary Alex Norris asked the legal regulator to tighten standards in sexual offence cases. The debate intensified after arguments used by Russell Brand’s defence during the trial that led to his conviction.
UK Justice Secretary Alex Norris has called for stronger action to stop defence barristers from relying on rape myths in court, after the controversy surrounding the strategy used in Russell Brand’s trial.
As reported by The Guardian and the BBC, Norris wrote to the Bar Standards Board (BSB), the body that regulates barristers, saying it was unacceptable to perpetuate false ideas about rape victims in court and warning that those who breach the rules could face disciplinary action, including being prevented from practising.
The dispute followed submissions by defence barrister Ian Winter KC during the case at Southwark Crown Court. According to both outlets, in his closing speech he questioned why Brand’s accusers had not fought back, screamed or tried to leave, and also asked the jury whether it could be sure that, among the many women the comedian had slept with over a decade, he had raped three.
Brand, 51, was convicted over attacks on four of the six women who gave evidence against him and was sentenced to 10 and a half years in prison for one count of rape and three sexual assaults, The Guardian and the BBC reported.
The BSB said, in remarks cited by both media organisations, that rape and sexual assault cases must be decided on evidence rather than prejudice. The Guardian added that the regulator said it had already set up an expert reference group to advise on stronger standards for barristers working on rape and other serious sexual offence cases.
The BBC also reported that the Ministry of Justice said Norris was determined to make protections for victims as strong as possible and stressed that rape myths have no place in court. It added that independent judges can already give directions to counter such myths, though the government wants to keep reviewing how the justice system handles victims of sexual violence.
The Bar Council, which represents barristers, argued that defendants who deny rape charges have a right to have evidence tested in court. According to The Guardian, it also stressed the importance of the BSB remaining independent from government. The BBC added that Kirsty Brimelow KC, chair of the Bar Council of England and Wales, said disciplinary powers already exist when the code of conduct is breached and warned that more mandatory training could worsen the shortage of barristers willing to defend rape and sexual assault cases.
The BBC further reported that the charity Rape Crisis said it is very common for people who experience rape or sexual abuse to find themselves unable to move or speak. It also said the judge in Brand’s case was praised for remarks made at sentencing to challenge rape myths. In those comments, Mr Justice Bennathan said that regardless of what women wear, where they go or what they drink, they retain the right to say no and to seek justice when someone acts without their consent.
Separately, The Guardian reported that Winter has referred himself to the BSB following criticism over both an exchange with a Sunday Times journalist outside court and his conduct during the trial.
The newspaper also said that Laura Brand, the convicted comedian’s wife, shared a message from him from prison in which he claimed he was not guilty of the offences for which he was jailed. In response, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband described the message as disgusting and said he regretted appearing on Brand’s online show in 2015 when he was Labour leader.
Also according to The Guardian, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy urged the entertainment industry to put its own systems in order or face government intervention. She is due to meet senior figures from media, arts and sport to push for protections for young workers and freelancers against harassment and abuse by older, more powerful men.
The same outlet added that Brand was transferred over the weekend from Wandsworth prison in London to HMP Littlehey in Cambridgeshire, which houses men convicted of sexual offences.
Sources
About this piece. Written by El Notero with AI assistance, from reporting published by the outlet cited above. El Notero did no original reporting on this story.





